
I told myself I was only interested in helping his brother. That explanation was becoming less convincing every day.
I Forgot I Was Supposed To Hate Him
Jack arrived at the diner carrying a folder so swollen it wouldn't close.
“Please tell me that's evidence,” I said.
“Mostly. There's also a parking ticket.”
“Yours?”
“Unfortunately.”
Nine days since he'd let me go, we'd met only in public over coffee and Eli's court papers. I hadn't decided what to do about the kidnapping. Jack never asked me to forget it.
I flipped through his folder. “You can't just confront witnesses.”
“I haven't.”
“You showed up at a man's workplace.”
“To ask if he remembered my brother.”
“That's confronting a witness.”
“He didn't remember me either.”
“I'm going to need stronger coffee.”
Jack smiled. I wished I hadn't noticed.
I'd found a lawyer willing to review Eli's conviction. Jack and I used public records and independent leads, never Vincent's confidences.
The problem was the main witness. His first statement said he hadn't seen the shooter's face. Months later, he'd identified Eli in court.
Jack tapped a name on the page. “This guy worked with him.”
“Have his number?”
“Back of the page.”
“See? You're trainable.”
“Don't get excited.”
We called together. The former coworker initially refused to discuss the trial, then stopped us before hanging up.
“He called me that night,” the man said. “Said he couldn't tell who he'd seen. I still have the voicemail. Kept it because the whole thing got weird.”
My pen froze.
“Please speak to the lawyer reviewing Eli's conviction,” I told him. “I'll give you her number.”
After the call, Jack stared at me.
“Is that good?”
“It's a lead. A real one. Don't start celebrating a miracle.”
He leaned back, hand over his face. His shoulders shook.
“Jack?”
He was laughing.
“I've been trying to get someone to listen for eight months,” he said.
Without thinking, I reached across the table and squeezed his hand.
It surprised both of us.
Over the next week, we talked about more than the case. He could fix anything except his cracked phone. I watched cooking shows while eating cereal over the sink.
“You terrify people for a living,” Jack said. “But you live like a student.”
“Students can't afford this cereal.”
I caught myself checking my phone for his messages.
By Friday, the other lawyer was moving Eli's case forward. I had no professional reason to invite Jack to my apartment.
I invited him anyway.
He arrived with takeout and a handbag.
I held it up. “What is this?”
“You said I owed you one.”
“Jack. It has a cartoon duck on it.”
“The woman at the store said it was popular.”
“She was making fun of you.”
“I suspected.”
I laughed so hard I had to put it down.
We ate on the sofa. The duck bag watched from the coffee table. When our shoulders touched, neither of us shifted away.
Jack put his plate aside. “Tessa, I need to say something.”
“Don't tell me you bought matching shoes.”
“I was wrong to take you. I know that doesn't disappear just because you can stand being around me now.”
“I know.”
“I'm not asking you to forget.”
His expression was serious. I put down my fork.
“I want to kiss you,” he said. “Which might be the stupidest thing I've said yet.”
“You have strong competition.”
He smiled, but he didn't move closer.
I remembered being afraid of him. I also remembered every time since then that I'd chosen to see him. He knew I could still report him. Neither of us had resolved that.
But tonight I wanted him here.
“Are you going to let me make a stupid decision too?” I asked.
“Only if you want to.”
I leaned in and kissed him.
Later, when Jack asked whether I was sure I wanted him to stay, I answered yes.
The bedroom door closed behind us.
In the morning, he made coffee so bad I accused him of poisoning me.
“You drank it,” he protested.
“I was being supportive.”
“You called it drain cleaner.”
“Constructive criticism.”
He kissed my forehead. I sat smiling into my mug.
Then my phone lit up.
Vincent Bellini.
I hear you've been keeping some interesting company.
From kidnapping to terrible coffee, Jack has certainly made an impression. Did you see that chemistry coming, or were you still rooting for Vincent at the beginning? Tell us your favorite Tessa and Jack moment. Something tells us their happiness will not stay uncomplicated for long.

