
I wanted to go home, forget his face, and never hear his name again. At least, that was the plan.
Why Did I Call Him Again
“Then let me out,” I said.
Jack stood by the back door, staring at his phone.
“Whatever Bellini did to your brother, I had nothing to do with it.”
“I know.”
“Great. Give me my phone.”
He laid it on the table. Nine percent battery. Fantastic.
“You can go,” Jack said.
I stared at him. “Just like that?”
“I've already made the worst decision of my life. I'm trying not to make another.”
He stepped away from the door. No bargain, no demand that I keep quiet. I stood on shaky knees.
I should have walked straight out.
Instead, I asked, “What did Eli actually do?”
Jack frowned.
“You said he was framed for murder. That doesn't mean he was innocent of everything.”
“He ran deliveries for Bellini's people. Cash, mostly. Sometimes packages he wasn't supposed to open.”
“And you knew?”
“I told him to quit.” Jack laughed bitterly. “When he got arrested, I thought prison might finally scare some sense into him.”
I waited.
“He called before sentencing. I didn't answer. Figured he wanted money or another favor.” He stared at the floor. “Now somebody's beating him in there, and I can't even reach him.”
I understood the guilt. I didn't excuse the kidnapping.
“I'm not forgiving you,” I said.
“I wasn't asking.”
“Good. You owe me a handbag, by the way. Mine's probably in a gutter.”
“I can pay for it.”
“With your ransom money?”
His mouth twitched despite himself.
“Give me your number,” I said.
Jack blinked. “Why?”
“Because I might have more questions. Don't get excited.”
He wrote it on a receipt. I took it, collected my phone and walked out.
The house was on an ordinary street, not some remote hideout. I called a cab from the convenience store at the corner.
At home, I locked both bolts and stood under the shower until the water ran cold.
Then I checked my messages.
One from Vincent.
Let me know when you're ready to discuss Thursday.
No Are you safe? Not even a Sorry about the kidnapping.
I called him.
“Tessa.” His voice was as smooth as ever. “I trust you're somewhere more comfortable.”
“You knew he had me.”
“I gathered that from the shouting.”
“And you hung up.”
“What did you expect? I can't negotiate with every lunatic who says he knows me.”
I thought about the umbrella. His wet shoulder. The way I'd smiled all the way home.
“I won't be representing you anymore,” I said.
Vincent paused. “You're upset.”
“Excellent observation.”
“Sleep on it. We'll speak tomorrow.”
“No, we won't.”
I hung up. I'd arrange my formal withdrawal and replacement counsel in the morning.
I sat on my bed, staring at my phone. I had every reason to report Jack. I still might. Nothing that had happened to Eli excused what he'd done to me.
But one thing kept bothering me.
Jack was certain his brother hadn't killed anyone. When I'd asked how he knew, he couldn't answer.
The next afternoon, I looked up Eli Callahan's case. Murder conviction. Eight months into a long sentence. A separate charge tied to the same criminal operation.
He hadn't been an innocent kid caught in a misunderstanding.
I read the appeal filings next.
One passage caught my eye. The prosecution's key witness had originally told police he couldn't see the shooter's face. At trial, he identified Eli.
It proved nothing. But it raised questions.
I stared at the number on Jack's receipt.
Calling my kidnapper was spectacularly stupid.
I called anyway.
“Hello?” Jack sounded wary.
“It's Tessa.”
A pause. “Is this about the handbag?”
“No. Listen carefully. I can't use anything Bellini told me as his lawyer. And I can't represent your brother. He needs independent counsel.”
“Okay,” Jack said slowly.
“But I've been reading the public record. There's something that deserves a closer look.”
“You read his case?”
“Don't sound so pleased. I'm still furious with you.”
“I know.” He hesitated. “Why are you helping?”
I looked at the testimony on my screen.
“Because your brother might be telling the truth,” I said. “And because somebody should check.”
Tessa was finally free, and somehow she ended up calling Jack anyway. Would you have helped his brother after everything that happened? Do you think Jack deserves another chance, or has he already crossed an unforgivable line? Let us know below.

